APTOPIX Peach Bowl Football

Mississippi running back Quinshon Judkins (4) runs into Penn State defensive end Jameial Lyons (19) during the second half of the Peach Bowl NCAA college football game, Saturday, Dec. 30, 2023, in Atlanta.

OFFENSE: Closed fast to make the numbers look good (510 yards, 343 passing yards), but the opposing defense wasn’t a great one. Amazing inablility to involve WRs, and strange inability to fully leverage the run game, were huge in this game and this season. Grade: D.

DEFENSE: Tough spot for these guys - new coordinator, critical opt-outs and a uniquely challenging scheme and set of skill-position weapons. Still, the Rebels had 540 yards, 30 first downs, and utterly closed the deal after halftime. Tough way for a great unit to bow out. Grade: C-minus.

SPECIAL TEAMS: Punter Riley Thompson averaged nearly 50 yards per kick. His effort was mostly nullified, for report card purposes, by Penn State having a field goal blocked. Overall, not much of a factor, but not a positive one. Grade: C-plus.

COACHING: This might be the toughest grade in report card history. It’s hard to know fully what Franklin and Co. were dealing with in the run-up to this game, but it obviously wasn’t favorable. The Lions played with good energy, but it was clearly a damaged football team in terms of the roster, the staff and, perhaps, the collective psyche. Grade: C.

What to Read Next